“Remembering speechlessly we seek the great forgotten language, the lost lane-end into heaven, a stone, a leaf, an unfound door. Where? When? O lost, and by the wind grieved, ghost, come back again.” Thomas Wolfe, Look Homeward, Angel
Recently a man renovating a house on East Chestnut Street found a box of letters and pictures, stored away years ago and long forgotten. Reluctant to throw away something that might be of historical significance, he brought the box to the North Carolina room of Pack Library and left it without giving his name. We want to thank our anonymous donor for this exciting photograph.
The signs on the buildings are our first clues to unlocking the secrets of the mystery photograph. Turn of the century Asheville City Directories show the business of architect and contractor James Albert Tennent at 20 South Court Square. (Court Square was renamed Pack Square around 1903.) The City Directory of 1896-97 is the first to list W. O. Wolfe’s monument shop, J. A. Tennent, and the office of African American attorney Harrison B. Brown all together at the corner of Market St. and Court Square. The Wolfe Building is easily identified in the photograph below of South Court Square, taken after the Commerce Building replaced the small building to the right of Tennent’s offices. Construction began on the Commerce Building in 1904. We now know WHERE? (in front of the W. O. Wolfe Building) and WHEN? (between 1896 and 1904).
But WHO are the children in the photograph? Because the location is the Wolfe Building, we looked at photographs of the Wolfe family around the turn of the century. The five children in the photo appear to be about as old as the Wolfe children would have been in 1899.
Our collection owns two photographs of members of the Wolfe family as they appeared in 1899, about a year before Thomas Wolfe was born. Above the family is gathered in the yard of 92 Woodfin Street on July 4, 1899. Mrs. Wolfe waited until her boys started school to cut their hair. In this photo, taken the summer before the twins began school, Grover’s hair is short, but Ben and his younger brother Fred still have long curls. Compare the faces of the boys with close ups of the boys in the wagon.
Our second picture above shows the Wolfe twins with their big boy hair cuts in the fall of 1899, standing with their class at Orange Street School. Grover and Ben are wearing sailor suits like the boys in the wagon. Again, compare the faces of the boys.
Our Mystery donation is a rare, intimate street-level view of the front of the monument shop of Thomas Wolfe’s father. The image is also important in that it shows buildings that no longer exist in other photos we have of the site. But is the photograph also a previously unknown portrait of Thomas Wolfe’s siblings? Join us in speculation about the identity of the people in the photograph. What are the chances that another group of five children, including a set of twins, of the same ages and sexes as the Wolfe children, would be posed so much at home in front of Wolfe’s monument shop?
Posted by Betsy Murray
Good work Betsy! I think you’ve shown that these are indeed the Wolfe children!
I’m with you and Dale. Too similar and too reasonable to NOT be the Wolfe kids. Just goes to show you never know what’s in that old shoebox in the attic.
Love this one Betsy! I think you’ve sleuthed a delight!
Wow I am really impressed with your work on this.
Two important items to mentioned: why have you not mentioned the woman in the car with the children? 1) How does she compare with contemporary photos of Julia Wolfe? 2) The African-American girl in front of Tennant’s store: could she be related to Harrison B. Brown? Does the census list daughters for him? How old was he circa 1899? The two “identical” puppies in the wagon seem like appropriate gifts for twin boys, so I think that supports the Wolfe identification.
There is a young, well-dressed African-American lass behind the cart and in front of Tennent’s enterprise. Could she be related Harrison B. Brown? Perhaps census records show he had a teenage daughter during this time period? Kudos on the great detective work so far.
My comments have been “awaiting moderation” fro almost a year now. Thank you.
Dear Barb, so sorry if your comments did not get approved. Perhaps one of us on staff was waiting to do further research and it got forgotten. The woman who wrote the blog has retired. I will add that we believe the woman to the side and the woman to the back of the cart are African American. –I would guess they are caretakers of the children in the cart. Zoe Rhine
Hi, Zoe. Thanks for your reply. I was wondering if the young woman on the sidewalk may be related to Harrison B. Brown, the attorney. Do census records show he had a daughter that would correspond to the date of the photo. The woman in the wagon does not look African American to me. Are there photos of Julia Wolfe from that period? Barb Hall